[Originals] Back Pack or Hip Pack, which is better?

On our outings, whether it's a more radical trail or a simple stroll, we always need to carry a few extras: water, snacks, phone, multi-tool, Co2, air camera, air pump, ID card, some cash, etc. As we can't fit everything in the pockets of our equipment, we usually resort to a backpack or fanny pack.

What I'm describing below is based on my experience and personal taste, I've used both and they always have the internal capacity to carry water. I'm not going to compare brands, volume or storage capacity, just the convenience of use.

Camelback ou Back Pack

The added value is undoubtedly the greater storage capacity, be it water or objects, as it has a larger size and more compartments. With the arrival of ebikes, there are even ones prepared to carry batteries! Another clear advantage is that it's easier to reach the drinking nozzle - some people can do it without having to take their hands off the handlebars. The main disadvantages will be discomfort due to the weight on the back/shoulders, great difficulty in accessing objects (who hasn't asked someone to take something out of or put something into their backpack) and, lastly, generating more heat as it doesn't make it easier for perspiration to dissipate.

Hip pack

The advantages include greater comfort, easier access to the objects we're carrying, a lower center of gravity (compared to a backpack), which allows us to be more agile on the bike, and improved body ventilation. Less positive is the smaller capacity for carrying gear and the less practical access to the drinking fountain. Personally, I prefer the waist bag. It causes me much less discomfort and allows me to move around better on the bike. It has less capacity, admittedly, but I make up for it with a small saddle bag where I carry an air camera and a multitool, and a bidon rack which also holds a small hand pump. In the bag, only water, phone, documents and a snak.

A piece of advice that applies to both backpacks and bags: make sure it always fits snugly to your body. There's nothing worse than having a backpack moving freely on your back or a saddle bag falling down your butt in the middle of a descent.

Have a good ride!